"As they passed the rows of houses they saw through the open doors that men were sweeping and dusting and washing dishes, while the women sat around in groups, gossiping and laughing. "What has happened?" the Scarecrow asked a sad-looking man with a bushy beard, who wore an apron and was wheeling a baby-carriage along the sidewalk. "Why, we've had a revolution, your Majesty -- as you ought to know very well," replied the man; "and since you went away the women have been running things to suit themselves. I'm glad you have decided to come back and restore order, for doing housework and minding the children is wearing out the strength of every man in the Emerald City." "Hm!" said the Scarecrow, thoughtfully. "If it is such hard work as you say, how did the women manage it so easily?" "I really do not know," replied the man, with a deep sigh. "Perhaps the women are made of cast-iron.""

- L. Frank Baum, "The Land of Oz"
Lost: Across The Sea

I'll be starting the live-blog of tonight's episode shortly. I'm expecting that all the "I want answers, now!" people will at least be somewhat sated after tonight's episode.

The title of this episode reminds me of the French song Shannon sang in the early part of Season one. Remember? "La Mer"?

Major Spoilers below the fold . . .

Lost. Wreckage of a boat . . . A pregnant lady in red who I don't recognize clings to the wreckage, as it and she is washed ashore on our favorite island O' mystery.

She makes her way to a river and sees the reflection in the water of a strange, non-English speaking lady wearing white. I can't tell what language is being spoken. Spanish I think?

The woman in red is named Claudia. They are sitting in the very caves where our Losties holed up back in Season one.

Now they are both speaking English.

"How did you get here?" Claudia asks the lady.

"Every question I answer will simply lead to another question." WORD!

Claudia starts going into loud, agonizing labor as she is midwifed by the lady. Out pops little Jacob!

But she's still (obviously) expecting, because she's still HUGE. I predict some Esau-ness is coming. And out he comes.

Jacob is wrapped in white swaddles, and BabyMIB in dark. The lady in white's face got all scared-looking when she first laid eyes on BabyMIB. She seems concerned. Very concerned. As the momma asks to hold the babies, the lady in white hits Jacob/BabyMIB's mom hard in the head with a rock, killing her.

At least she said she was sorry.

**** Commercial *****

Back to the beach. A young, dark-clad boy picks up something (a box? Maybe a Locke Box? Oh, it's a backgammon set). The twins start to play, because LittleMIB "just knows" how to play.

LittleMIB tells Jacob to promise not to tell Mother that they are playing.

"So, do you want to play or don't you Jacob?"

"Yes, I want to play." And so it starts.

Later in the caves. Creepy mom: "Where's your brother?"

He's down at the beach, watching the water.

"Do you love me, Jacob?"

"Yes."

"Then tell me what happened."

Mother strolls down to the beach, where LittleMIB is.

"May I join you?"

"Sure. Jacob told you what I found."

She tells him that Jacob isn't like him. LittleMIB is "special"?

"Can I keep the game?"

"Of course you can. That's why I left it for you."

He thinks it came from across the sea.

"There is no where else. The island is all there is."

She explains that he and Jacob came from her, and she came from her mother, who is now dead.

"What's 'dead'?"

"Something you'll never have to worry about."

Later, the boys are chasing a boar, but someone else gets to it first. Savages. The boys hide. When the savages take off, the boys run back to tell their mother.

"Where did they come from. They looked like us!"

"They're not like us. We're here for a reason."

"What reason?"

[insert standard Lost "There's no time to explain" excuse here. They'll just have to trust her, etc. etc.]

As they walk through the jungle, the boys blindfolded, she explains that men are all the same. They come, they destroy, etc.

LittleMIB looks like Zac Effron, by the way.

She explains that they are different, because they can never hurt each other.

They walk toward a very Cair Paravel/Narnia-looking glowing cave. She forbids them from going down there. It's full of light. "The warmest, brightest light you've ever felt."

This is a little bit of the same light that is inside of every man. If the light goes out here, she tells them, it goes out everywhere.

She tells them that they will protect this place, forever. Well, at least one of them will.

Zac smiles.

***** Commercial *****

The boys, back to the game. White rocks, black rocks, and Jacob is cheating. LittleZac made the rules of the game, of course. Just then their real mother shows up, but only Zac can see her.

He takes off, saying he's going for a walk, but instead finds his mom. She informs him that she's dead. She wants to show him something. "Where you came from. It's across the island, a place you've never seen."

She shows him the village where the other people on her ship have settled, and tells him that they came across the sea. Where he came from as well.

And, by the way, your "mother" is not your mother. "I am"

Cave camp, LittleMIB wakes up Jacob as fakeMom sleeps. They travel by torch. "We're leaving, and we're never coming back."

"Where?"

"To the people. They're our people."

When LittleMIB tells Jacob that she's not even their mother, Jacob begins to beat the tar out of him. FakeMom breaks up the fight.

LittleMIB confronts her. "You killed my mother." He's going to go across the sea. He implores Jacob to come with him, but we both know that's not going to happen.

FakeMom: "Whatever you have been told, you will never be able to leave this island."

He tells her that he's going to prove her wrong and walks away.

Cut to mom and Jacob on the beach. She admits to having killed their mother. "If I had let her live, she would have taken you back to her people, and those people are bad. Very bad."

"Am I good mother?"

"Yes!"

"Then why do you love littleMIB more than me?"

"I love you in . . in different ways." Reassuring. I love it when my Mom tells me that too . . .

"Will you stay with me Jacob. Please?"

"Yes . . . for awhile."

Side note: Interesting how Jacob, littleMIB and FakeMom had their own Others to deal with. Kind of a constant theme on this show . . .

***** Commercial *****

Jacob is grown up, and has learned to use the loom/big knitting thing. Momma's there too, looking no better for the wear.

Jacob observes his brother, the MIB we now all recognize, living among the natives.

Jacob and MIB play backgammon. Jacob is watching the people, because he wants to know if mother is right.

One thing's for sure. The proto-Others may be not be bad, but they sure are covered in dirt.

MIB thinks they are bad (he's dirty too). But they are a means to an end. He's going to leave. He found a way off the island.

"That's impossible. There is no way off the island."

In answer, MIB throws a dagger against a magnetic well. Evidently there are places all over this island where metal behaves strangely.

MIB tells him that when they find those places, they dig. And they've found something.

Jacob is disconcerted. He doesn't want to leave this island. He doesn't believe that his mother will die.

MIB: "Everything dies." He's certainly not that much like Zac Effron anymore.

Jacob tells his Mom that MIB has found a way to leave the island.

Mother goes to look into things, spying on the villagers. She comes upon MIB, working his smithy. She startles him, and he pulls a knife.

"May I join you?"

"Yes. How are you?"

"I'm worried."

"Well, you should be." MIB hasn't been able to find the light under the island. He's been trying to figure out how to reach it.

She tells him he has no idea what he's in for.

"I have no idea, because you wouldn't tell me." Story of our lives.

He digs out part of the wall, and there's the golden light. Well, maybe. It might just be sunlight.

He points out a wheel. He's going to attach the wheel, somehow, to the light. And then he's going to turn it, and leave the island.

"I'm special, mother."

"Then, I suppose this is goodbye," she says.

She reaches to hug him. They embrace, and they both look sad. I'm wondering if she's going to try and off him.

"I am so sorry," she says as she smashes his head against the wall. Yep, saw that coming.

***** Commercial *****

It is night. Jacob sleeps.

His mother wakes him up. "It's time."

"Something happened, didn't it."

She claims to have let MIB go.

They walk off by torchlight to the Cave of Golden Light.

"What's down there?"

"Life, Death, Rebirth. It's the source, the heart of the island. Just promise me. No matter what you do, you will never go down there."

If he did, it would be worse than dying. Much worse.

She uncorks the wine bottle from a few shows ago, and begins to incant something in a different language. She hands him a glass. "Drink this."

"What happens if I do?"

It's his commitment to protect this place. He doesn't want to. He knows that MIB was her favorite, "And now I'm all you have."

She tells him he doesn't really have a choice. "Take the cup and drink."

He takes and drinks. Is this eternal life?

"Now, you and I are the same," she tells him.

Cut to daylight and MIB, passed out on the ground. He comes to. He's kinda bloody.

He sees that his well has been filled in. Man!

Behind his shoulder, he sees the smoke of his burning village. Everyone's dead, so I'm not sure what happened. My guess is that Crazy had something to do with this.

He finds his backgammon set in the ashes and starts to cry.

***** Commercial *****

Conversation on the couch . . .

Daughters and wife are grumbling . . .

Me, trying to be reassuring: "They're giving us answers every week!"

Bethany: "THEY'RE GIVING US ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WE AREN'T ASKING!!"

Molly: "All I want to know is will Kate choose Jack or Sawyer."

**********************

I see a beach, and new characters, and so naturally I assume this is Lost. But it's Brothers and Sisters.

Still commercials . . .

**********************

Jacob and Mom walk.

"Storm coming."

"Yes there is. You should go, get some firewood."

She tells him to be careful, and that she'll see him back home, but I doubt it.

She walks up to the caves. It's dark, and stuff has been messed with. She finds the backgammon set, and pulls out a black and a white rock.

She gets stabbed by MIB. I saw that coming but didn't have time to blog it before it happened. He looks sad.

"Why wouldn't you let me leave, Mother?"

"Because, I love you. Thank you." She dies.

Just then Jacob shows up. "What did you do?" He attacks MIB and starts beating the living crud out of him. MIB may be pretty good with a knife, but Jacob is golden gloves, baybee.

Jacob drags MIB down a jungle trail.

"You can't kill me Jacob. She made it that way. You can't!"

"Don't worry brothah brother, I'm not going to."

Jacob sends MIB down the river into the Cave of Golden Light. When MIB hits the cave, he gets "flushed", kind of, the light goes out and Smokie emerges.

Jacob washes his face off at the river. Off to the side he sees his brother's dead body, lying on some rocks, tangled in some limbs.

Adam and Eve. Mom and MIB.

He carries the body back to the caves, and lays MIB by Mom. I totally called that (well, ten seconds ago).

He puts the black and white rocks in a pouch. The same pouch (the show helpfully flashes forawrd) that Kate and Jack found.

Jacob puts their hands together as the flash-forwards to the Season One cave scene intersperse.

"Goodbye brother. Goodbye."

Sad.

The song The End, by the Doors, plays as we see various Losties reflected in mirrors.

BAD WOBOT!!!

Trackbacks:

Trackback URL: http://thinklings.org/bloo.trackback.php/5973.

Comments on "Lost: Across The Sea":
1. Shrode - 05/11/2010 9:37 pm CDT

Great episode.

Not much in the way of answers though. The one person who seemed to know stuff was killed. And she was crazy. Even Jacob and MIB don't know everything about the island. So we'll never totally know all that...

I did find out that my theory was wrong. Except I did say they were brothers. And the light could still have something to do with Eden...And smokey might be the angel God left to protect Eden.

My wife and I debated this: Did Jacob's no-name brother turn into Smokey-spirit creature, and left his body behind OR...

was Smokey imprisoned down there, and no-name released him, and so Smokey has just been taking that form all these years?

I think the latter.

I think the lady was speaking Latin by the way. Pretty sure the short sword was Roman. So I'm dating these events to the time of the Roman empire.

When they switched to English that was just for the benefit of the viewers. They were "speaking Latin" the entire episode.

2. Molly - 05/11/2010 9:56 pm CDT

Okay, I should have gotten WAY more credit in that live-blog. I was the one who first said that little MIB looks like a mini Zak Efron.

And, just to clarify, when I said that I only wanted to know who Kate will choose, I was being funny.

Otherwise, great Live-blog, daddy ;).

3. Bill - 05/11/2010 10:09 pm CDT

Thanks Sweetie.

Great episode, I thought. We got lots of answers:

Jacob and MIB are twin brothers, sons of Lilith (I'm going with that for now, Shrode).

She was immortal. She was also the Smoke monster, pledged to protect the light of life. Before she died she made Jacob immortal (she had already made MIB immortal - he was her favorite) so he could take on the protection of the light. MIB took over for her as smoke monster.

(We know she was a smokie because she was able to wipe out the village)

Her motives were, I believe, good, although they led her to murders. She fears that man will discover the light and put it out.

MIB wants to leave the island. Still. Evidently if he does (I still am not sure why) the light of the world will go out.

Maybe Smokie isn't MIB. Maybe MIB really is dead and Smokie just looks like him (or looked like him before the Locke-look he now has) but I'm not sure.

4. Manders - 05/11/2010 10:22 pm CDT

I think Smokey is whatever the Mysterious Island Light transmogrified MIB's soul into after it killed him. He--like Michael and the whispery ghosts--is another soul that can't move on. But why?

My friend has the theory that sacrificing MIB to the light may have released Smokey, which was living down there already. *shrug*

GAH, this show.

5. GinH - 05/11/2010 10:32 pm CDT

Crazy mom said if you go into the light something worse than death will happen so that makes me think MIB turned into smoke monster and that's what's worse than dying. I wonder if the light disappeared when smokie came up and that's why Jacob insists he stay cuz MIB is also somehow the light?

6. Bill - 05/12/2010 6:47 am CDT

I think being Smokie would be kinda cool, actually :-)

7. GinH - 05/12/2010 7:38 am CDT

Seems like it would be, but maybe the whole killing bad people thing isn't as great as dying yourself? LOL

8. Riley - 05/12/2010 7:54 am CDT

A few questions that will probably never be answered at this point but will be speculated ad nauseum:

-What is the light?
-How did it get there?
-Who is Mother and what are her origins?

I'm a little more concerned with the first two, and honestly a little more concerned with the second one. Origins are always a little more interesting to me than finding out what the thing is.

Thoughts?

9. Riley - 05/12/2010 8:20 am CDT

A few questions that will probably never be answered at this point but will be speculated ad nauseum:

-What is the light?
-How did it get there?
-Who is Mother and what are her origins?

I'm a little more concerned with the first two, and honestly a little more concerned with the second one. Origins are always a little more interesting to me than finding out what the thing is.

Thoughts?

10. jen - 05/12/2010 9:07 am CDT

I'm still noodling this episode - it left me slightly dissatisfied but I can't pin down why. And I wonder how they'll wrap things up in 3.5 hours.

11. Quaid - 05/12/2010 1:01 pm CDT

I think dissatisfaction may stem from the fact that the story wasn't advanced as much as holes in the back story were filled up.

They've done this in seasons past when they will take the third or fourth to last episode and use it to fill in gaps. I kind of look at it as a necessary evil (no pun intended) in order to augment the final episodes. Instead of interspersing backstory within the current plot lines, as they usually do, this enables the show to focus more on advancing what happens in the final hours of the show.

I don't expect them to do this next week - my guess is that they'll return to the island now that we know more about its "power" and the purposes of Jacob and the Candidate.

Riley - we may discover some of those answers via Hurley's spiritvision. I have a feeling that the Candidate will want to know more about what he'll be protecting in next week's eps.

12. Andrew - 05/12/2010 1:41 pm CDT

My dream scenario for next week:

Jacob appears to Jack, and says, "Are you ready to know about the island?"

Jack says, "Yes. Yes, I am."

Jacob says, "Good," and proceeds to sit with him for a full hour, explaining, in detail, the what, how, why, and when of the island.

That leaves two and a half hours for the plot itself to advance toward the end. And, having eliminated all the extra time the characters would have spent trying to figure out the mystery for themselves, that's a very action-packed two and a half hours.

Cheap? Maybe. The best possible scenario for convincing me they (the writers) actually know what they are doing? Probably.

13. Michele - 05/12/2010 2:23 pm CDT

I thought the ep. felt cheesy and slow. I was disappointed they used a familiar actress for the mom, it was sort of distracting. I think they switched to English because they really did switch, and I wonder why. It also bothered me how they had to flashback to Jack and Kate in the Adam and Eve scene like we're retarded. It sort of ruined the moment.

14. Riley - 05/12/2010 2:38 pm CDT

Andrew, somehow I hope you're right... A nice expositional reveal would be much appreciated. But you know, somehow, I simultaneously hope also for mystery... The only way LOST will be LOST when it's over. The mystery has to live for the essence of the show to live.

Now, do I think we know enough to wrap up a six-season-long question of "what is the island?" answered by mere inferences and slight answers? No. But I don't think we will know everything by the time the show is over.

15. Bill - 05/12/2010 2:47 pm CDT

It also bothered me how they had to flashback to Jack and Kate in the Adam and Eve scene like we're retarded. It sort of ruined the moment.

Overall I really liked this ep (because the Jacob/MIB backstory has fascinated me. I realize I may be in a minority there) but I thought the flash-forwards at the end were VERY heavy handed. Like we wouldn't have caught that otherwise.

Now, that being said, I didn't remember the pouch with the black/white rocks, but I would have probably caught that eventually in reading forums or maybe even in re-watching Season 1 (which is still the best season of Lost, in my op).

On a very side note, that may not make sense: Knowing Adam and Eve were a mom and the son who killed her was kind of . . . ew.

I think the series will end with ambiguity. By design.

16. Andrew - 05/12/2010 5:23 pm CDT

But you know, somehow, I simultaneously hope also for mystery... The only way LOST will be LOST when it's over. The mystery has to live for the essence of the show to live.

As much as I appreciate the appeal to mystery and faith, I don't see how it would leave me satisfied. This isn't The Sopranos. There are some questions I will take ambiguity on (I would be perfectly fine not knowing who Kate chooses, for instance), but there are certain questions that need to be answered, especially if there are characters on the island who, presumably, know the answers. The essential questions were all raised in the first season, and the writers have had five entire seasons to try and answer them (at least one of which was a complete waste of airtime).

When the screen went black at the end of The Sopranos, I felt satisfied. It wasn't genius, but it wasn't cheap either. I don't know if it could have ended any other way.

If we get to the end of Lost and the screen simply goes black, leaving us to speculate until God comes back, I will throw a fit. That's worse than a cop-out, that's betrayal.

17. jen - 05/12/2010 6:36 pm CDT

I don't think who Kate chooses matters. It's who Sawyer chooses that matters. He chose Juliet. He won't go back to Kate after experiencing the love he had with Juliet. Even if alternaLOSTiverse is where it all ends up.

18. Jared - 05/12/2010 6:43 pm CDT

When the screen went black at the end of The Sopranos, I felt satisfied. It wasn't genius, but it wasn't cheap either. I don't know if it could have ended any other way.

Andrew, I've been thinking of this show ending and The Sopranos a lot lately too. Both shows managed to transcend the limitations of television, include a variety of strong characters and multiple layers of story, and suck viewers into their worlds. And of course I haven't had the anticipation/anxiety about a show ending this way since Sopranos.

Like you I was satisfied with the Sopranos ending, but of course was left wanting more.
And like you, if LOST ends similarly, I will find it very disappointing. LOST raised too many mysteries to leave threads dangling. (Sopranos saved one of its few mysteries for that final second. :-)

19. Alan K. Henderson - 05/13/2010 12:31 am CDT

Idea for an SNL skit: the cast is fed up with the direction of Lost, they enlist Hiro Nakamura from "Heroes" to change the past so that the show's creators will crank out a sane script. But in the big showdown, Hiro pushes J. J. Abrams down a DHARMA hatch, and Abrams emerges as the Smoke Monster. Hiro says, "Maybe I'll have better luck with Battlestar Galactica" - and promptly vanishes.

20. DaBomb - 05/13/2010 6:31 pm CDT

the Jacob/MIB backstory has fascinated me. I realize I may be in a minority there

I'm with you on that one Bill. And I agree with Quaid that this was also necessary to avoid having to move back and forth between answering background questions and advancing plot in the final episode.

I enjoyed the episode and I think I like the theory that when MIB was thrown into the cave his soul was transmorphed into the figure of the smoke monster... I think. I just really don't know. I feel like my brain just had a tickle fight with Lost, and it needs to calm down before it can comprehend all the tickling that just went on.

21. Bobbi - 05/14/2010 9:17 pm CDT

I watched the first season of Lost and I was lost. So I'm glad I found this blog. Now I don't have to watch Lost. I can just read the blog! Thanks. I think this show is based on somebody's recurrent nightmare. I've seen some movies based on nightmares! Not satisfying at all. But my hat is off to all of you for hanging in there!

Leave a Comment:
Name:
URL: (optional)
Email: (optional - will not be published)
Comment:

Please enter the characters you see in the above CAPTCHA image:


Notify me via email if any followup comments are added to this post (show help)